One Piece Episode 584: A Swordplay Showdown! Brook vs. the Mysterious Torso Samurai!
Canon/MED
OSHIMETER
8.9
56 Fans
5
4
3
2
1
PacingVisualWritingEmo ImpactSoundtrack
LIVE · THE WEEKLY VERDICT
One Piece Episode 584: A Swordplay Showdown! Brook vs. the Mysterious Torso Samurai!
Canon/MED
OSHIMETER
8.9
56 Fans
5
4
3
2
1
PacingVisualWritingEmo ImpactSoundtrack
QUICK TAKES
shinobu_sting_130
When you see Law showing up as a Warlord it feels like a massive shift and him standing his ground against Smoker makes the whole Punk Hazard mystery feel much more dangerous now
franky_fiesta_65
Smoker smashing those marines into the wall for being annoying was hilarious and the whole doorbell scene actually being in the manga makes it even better
black
I can't believe Brook finally found someone to tell his skull jokes to and the fact that it was a literal floating torso makes it ten times better
fukase_firefly
My head is spinning trying to figure out how that samurai torso can talk without any lungs or a mouth and Brook just treats it like a normal tuesday
mumen_rider
Brook using his skull jokes against that actual floating torso had me laughing so hard and it fits his fighting style perfectly
sailor_lead_crow
I couldn't stop laughing when Smoker started tossing his own Marines around for being idiots because he has zero patience for their nonsense today
goku_guardian
My skin crawled when Law was revealed as a Warlord because of that terrifying story about him collecting pirate hearts just to get the title from the government
muso
Those centaurs are so weird and it is hard to tell if they were born that way or if Law did some weird surgery on them using his fruit powers
anya_alstreim
Knowing that Law is now a Warlord changes how you view his actions, especially since we still do not know if he is actually on their side or not
jushiro_jubei
Smoker showing up on the island and immediately looking for a fight with Law is going to be such a mess and the tension is actually getting good
blue
The mystery of why there are centaurs and dragons on this island is only getting more confusing and Law being there makes it even better
rayquaza_306
I honestly thought the first half was dragging a bit with the giant kids and the centaurs but everything changed the second Law stepped out of that building. Hearing that he became a Warlord and handed over those hearts was such a shock and now I have so many questions about why he is even on this frozen island.
destron
Waiting through all that running around in the snow just to get to the end was a bit much but Smoker spamming that doorbell like a maniac made the marine scene way better
sailor_aluminum_seiren_391
It is weird watching those giant kids cry while Nami tries to help them and the whole vibe of this facility is getting really creepy
midoriya_mighty
Whoa, that headless samurai fighting Brook was something else; I totally wasn't expecting it to be such a formidable opponent with two swords! How is it even moving like that without a brain or a heart, much less keeping up with Brook? It honestly made me laugh and freak out a little at the same time.
corkus_the_cynic_192
Seeing those enormous kids begging for help totally threw me off, I wasn't expecting their situation to be so genuinely heartbreaking when the Straw Hats were just trying to figure out what was going on. It really made me worry about what kind of messed up stuff led to them being in that state.
jiraiya_jester_50
The story about Law sending a hundred pirate hearts to the Marines is so dark and it makes you wonder what his real plan is
vanessa_valkyrie_142
That last scene with Law stepping out of the building was such a huge moment and his new coat looks so much cooler than his old outfit
setsuna_meioh
I actually had to pause when they mentioned Law handed over a hundred hearts to become a Warlord because he always seemed like a cool guy but that is straight up villain behavior. It makes so much more sense why there are random body parts running around everywhere now and Brook fighting that torso was easily the funniest part of the whole week
michiru_kaioh_370
The middle of the episode felt a little bit slow, but at least the fight between Brook and the samurai torso had some funny jokes to keep things moving along
EPISODE CONTEXT
This episode builds on the Straw Hats' initial exploration of the mysterious island introduced in the preceding episodes, deepening the bizarre encounters and unanswered questions that began around Episode 583. Brook and Luffy take center stage as the crew fragments across the island, each group peeling back a new layer of danger and weirdness. The groundwork laid here — new adversaries, the enigmatic samurai, and the island's escalating strangeness — feeds directly into Episode 585's anticipated revelations and deeper character interactions.
QUICK TAKES
shinobu_sting_130
When you see Law showing up as a Warlord it feels like a massive shift and him standing his ground against Smoker makes the whole Punk Hazard mystery feel much more dangerous now
franky_fiesta_65
Smoker smashing those marines into the wall for being annoying was hilarious and the whole doorbell scene actually being in the manga makes it even better
black
I can't believe Brook finally found someone to tell his skull jokes to and the fact that it was a literal floating torso makes it ten times better
fukase_firefly
My head is spinning trying to figure out how that samurai torso can talk without any lungs or a mouth and Brook just treats it like a normal tuesday
mumen_rider
Brook using his skull jokes against that actual floating torso had me laughing so hard and it fits his fighting style perfectly
sailor_lead_crow
I couldn't stop laughing when Smoker started tossing his own Marines around for being idiots because he has zero patience for their nonsense today
goku_guardian
My skin crawled when Law was revealed as a Warlord because of that terrifying story about him collecting pirate hearts just to get the title from the government
muso
Those centaurs are so weird and it is hard to tell if they were born that way or if Law did some weird surgery on them using his fruit powers
anya_alstreim
Knowing that Law is now a Warlord changes how you view his actions, especially since we still do not know if he is actually on their side or not
jushiro_jubei
Smoker showing up on the island and immediately looking for a fight with Law is going to be such a mess and the tension is actually getting good
blue
The mystery of why there are centaurs and dragons on this island is only getting more confusing and Law being there makes it even better
rayquaza_306
I honestly thought the first half was dragging a bit with the giant kids and the centaurs but everything changed the second Law stepped out of that building. Hearing that he became a Warlord and handed over those hearts was such a shock and now I have so many questions about why he is even on this frozen island.
destron
Waiting through all that running around in the snow just to get to the end was a bit much but Smoker spamming that doorbell like a maniac made the marine scene way better
sailor_aluminum_seiren_391
It is weird watching those giant kids cry while Nami tries to help them and the whole vibe of this facility is getting really creepy
midoriya_mighty
Whoa, that headless samurai fighting Brook was something else; I totally wasn't expecting it to be such a formidable opponent with two swords! How is it even moving like that without a brain or a heart, much less keeping up with Brook? It honestly made me laugh and freak out a little at the same time.
corkus_the_cynic_192
Seeing those enormous kids begging for help totally threw me off, I wasn't expecting their situation to be so genuinely heartbreaking when the Straw Hats were just trying to figure out what was going on. It really made me worry about what kind of messed up stuff led to them being in that state.
jiraiya_jester_50
The story about Law sending a hundred pirate hearts to the Marines is so dark and it makes you wonder what his real plan is
vanessa_valkyrie_142
That last scene with Law stepping out of the building was such a huge moment and his new coat looks so much cooler than his old outfit
setsuna_meioh
I actually had to pause when they mentioned Law handed over a hundred hearts to become a Warlord because he always seemed like a cool guy but that is straight up villain behavior. It makes so much more sense why there are random body parts running around everywhere now and Brook fighting that torso was easily the funniest part of the whole week
michiru_kaioh_370
The middle of the episode felt a little bit slow, but at least the fight between Brook and the samurai torso had some funny jokes to keep things moving along
LIVE · THE WEEKLY VERDICT
©東映・東映アニメーション・集英社・フジテレビ・バンダイ ©尾田栄一郎／集英社・フジテレビ・東映アニメーション
AnimeOshi.com refers to anime titles, character names, logos, and other trademarked or copyrighted materials to identify and describe the works being reviewed, discussed, ranked or otherwise referenced on this site. This usage is believed to be nominative fair use or non-infringing and is not intended to imply any affiliation with the respective rights holders.
All trademarks and copyrights remain the property of their owners. If you are a rights holder and have concerns about any content on this site, please contact us at legal@animeoshi.com